hairylunch (hairylunch) wrote,


So, I saw a presentation about retirement the other day, and putting money into a 457 Deferred Comp. I was thinking does it make more sense to put money into the 457 or into a Roth. The main difference would be that the 457 doesn't have taxes upfront, but instead you pay at the end, whereas with the Roth you only pay taxes on what you pay in the beginning.

A bit of thinking about this, and then I realized that it theoretically shouldn't make a difference - multiplication is associative. So, let's say I have principle x, that my income tax is y percent, the interest rate is z, and I'll invest for n years. With the 457 you get:
With the Roth:
Mathematically the two are the same, assuming that the interest rate and the tax rate would stay the same. There shouldn't be any difference in the interest rates, and by the time I'm withdrawing money from either of these, I'll be retired and in the low income tax bracket anyway.

Of course, psychologically a non-Roth will seem a bit tough, since the taxes you pay will be so much higher in the absolute sense . . .

On a side note I just finished my taxes . . . took me all of 15 minutes, though it did cost me $30. There were cheaper options online, but since I've used H&R Block in the past, I kept using their online service . . . so free federal, and I had to pay for filing the state return . . .
Tags: investment, money, taxes

  • new digs

    I've moved to! I've been on LiveJournal since the navel-gazing days of blogging, even paying for a…

  • Portland and Protests

    Truth is complicated. Memes and tweets serve as news for many today, and folks cherry pick their sources and the items they want to believe.…

  • Random Thoughts

    Lots of time to listen to podcasts and think/process these days . . . a few items that have been percolating in my brain ... Being a poet/imposter…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.